Supergirl

While celebrating her 23^rd birthday off-planet, Kara “Supergirl” Zor-El (Milly Alcock) encounters young Ruthye Knoll (Eve Ridley), who attempts to enlist her in her quest for revenge against Brigand leader Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts), who murdered her parents. Though disinclined to help at first, Supergirl soon finds herself drawn into the fray, racing against the clock to save one of her closest companions.

For the past fifteen years or so, DC’s cinematic offerings have been uneven (to put it charitably). If Supergirl is anything to go by, that’s a trend that shows no signs of changing under James Gunn’s DC Studios watch.

First, the good: for all of the baseless carping over her casting, Alcock does quite well in the title role. She’s positioned as a cynical counterpoint to her nerdy cousin Superman (David Corensweat), and her sloppy, drunken antics bear that out. However, the film’s exploration of her backstory lets Alcock show her range and give Kara depth in the process. The other standout performance arguably belongs to Jason Momoa as the fearsome bounty hunter Lobo (who seems to be having a blast), but his screentime and impact on the story are both negligible. Though the visual darkness sometimes makes the action difficult to follow, Craig Gillespie’s direction is at least energetic, and there are a few eye-popping moments.

That said, Supergirl is narratively weak. Though based on Tom King and Bilquis Evely’s well-regarded Woman of Tomorrow comic book series, Ana Noguiera’s writing is a thinly-plotted hash of cinematic cliches that can’t help but evoke better-made films. You’ll find traces of everything from Mad Max: Fury Road to True Grit and more here. Schoenaerts as Krem is contemptible but forgettable, and the hamminess of the performance works against the character’s menace.  

Warner Brothers has been responsible for so many lackluster-to-dreadful DC adaptations that it’s hard to come down too hard on Supergirl, which at least manages to be sometimes fun. However, it’s both a step down from its immediate predecessor (2025’s Superman) and a plea to get Alcock some better material to work with.