Discovered by Danish sailors, a seriously injured Victor Frankenstein (Oscar Isaac) tells their captain (Lars Mikkelson) the tale of the creature (Jacob Elordi) who is relentlessly pursuing him. Victor, an aristocratic surgeon, created the creature, but his pride at his achievement turns to frustration and rejection. But the creature, whom Victor regards as a monstrous mistake, has a tale of his own to tell.
Finding the beauty in the horrifying and grotesque has been one of writer-director Guillermo del Toro’s unifying themes, and so it seemed almost inevitable that he would get around to adapting Mary Shelley’s classic novel one of these days. Del Toro’s version definitely bears his imprint while still remaining faithful to the spirit though not the letter of the source material.
Unsurprisingly, Frankenstein is a visually striking film. The costume design is impeccable, and the sets – from Victor’s towering Gothic laboratory to the frigid stillness of the Arctic – lend weight to the proceedings. This version of the creature also looks the most like what the text suggests he should: a stitched-together human.
While del Toro showed fidelity in that regard and honored the text’s Gothic/Romantic roots in other ways, he did make quite a few character changes. The William of the film (Felix Kammerer) is a combination of Victor’s younger brother and his friend Henry, and a new benefactor character has been added. He’s played by Christoph Waltz, which should keep complaints about the invention to a minimum. More controversially, Elizabeth (Mia Goth) has a far more adversarial relationship with Victor, whose selfishness is turned up just as the creature’s murderousness in the course of revenge is downplayed. This serves to render the creature more sympathetic and supports del Toro’s humanistic vision though it’s handled a bit ham-handedly and robs the film of some of its tragic potency.
Regardless, the cast is in good form here. Isaac captures not only Victor’s egomaniacal obsessiveness but also his later regret. Though Elizabeth feels shoehorned into being the film’s conscience, Goth still gives her a bit of an edge. Elordi, however, outshines everyone here on sheer range, convincingly playing the creature as innocently naïve, vengeful, pitiful, and terrifyingly vicious, at different points.
Remakes of
oft-adapted classics fight an uphill battle to avoid feeling either superfluous
or blasphemous. Del Toro capably dodged both those bullets, and while the end
result can feel narratively constrained, on a stylistic level, it’s alive!



