Odysseus
(Matt Damon), King of Ithaca, reluctantly leaves home to support the war
efforts of Agamemnon (Benny Safdie) and his brother Menelaus (Jon Bernthal) against
Troy to force the return of the latter’s wife, Helen (Lupita Nyongo). After
Odysseus engineers a plan that leads to the sacking of Troy, he and his men take
a slower route home. Along the way, they encounter monsters that threaten their
survival and tempt the wrath of the gods. Meanwhile, Odysseus’s wife, Penelope
(Ann Hathaway) fends off many suitors in his absence, hoping for his return
while their son Telemachus (Tom Holland) seeks news of his fate
Given the
scope and scale of his last movie (2023’s Oppenheimer), it seemed
fitting that Christopher Nolan would turn his attention toward a mythological
epic. He delivers adroit, suspenseful visual storytelling and gets a lot out of
his talented cast, but some of his creative choices leave the film feeling a
bit hollow.
As with
the director’s prior work, Nolan’s attention to detail and choice of composer
make for a spectacle that commands our attention. From the chaotic combat of
battle-ravaged Troy to the lonesome beauty of Ogygia, The Odyssey is visually diverse
enough to offset any tedium that might otherwise arise from watching dudes sail
aimlessly for three hours. Ludwig Gonarsson’s score is arguably the tensest put
to a Nolan film, which, given Dunkirk and Oppenheimer, is saying quite
a lot. When paired with the gruesome design of Polyphemus the Cyclops and sickening
transformations that the witch Circe (Samantha Morton) brings about, The
Odyssey plays like a horror film at times, a counterbalance to its more
somber and sentimental moments.
The
biggest bone of contention is not Nolan’s craftsmanship but rather the modern
sensibility he brings to the source material. This goes beyond casting choices
(the subject of inane complaints from Internet trolls), contemporary idiom, and
American accents and extends to the film’s themes. Damon’s Odysseus is haunted
by the atrocities of war, which will resonate with post-Vietnam,
post-Iraq/Afghanistan Americans but also plays as anachronistic given the
setting. The gods, central figures in myth, are reduced to peripheral
presences, save for Odysseus’s recurring visions of Athena (played by Zendaya). The overt call for human beings to treat one another better, while channeling the classical importance of "guest-friendship," seems more a palliative for our current sociopolitical situation than anything else. Collectively, these moves are akin to putting on a costume that looks splendid
but just doesn’t quite fit right. And yet, if Nolan didn’t bring something
novel to the table, this latest version of an oft-told tale might have lost its
raison d’etre. To Hades if you do, to Hades if you don’t.
Fortunately,
the cast makes for a fairly effective diversion from this bit of
disappointment. Hathaway breathes fire into what could have been a one-note “grieving
(de facto) widow” role. Robert Pattinson makes for a love-to-hate villain as
the slimy, conspiratorial suitor Antinuous. John Leguizamo, handed a rare
straight dramatic role as loyal swineherd Ememaus, showcases range that he
rarely gets to put to use. Casting the Harvard-educated Damon as the smart guy
among the Greek forces makes sense on a meta level, and he certainly brings
anguish and conviction (to say nothing of an unintentionally funny Boston
accent) to the role, but the absence of Odysseus’s trickster qualities really
flattens the character.
All told, The
Odyssey is a rousing, eminently watchable film whose pointed stabs at
contemporary relevance sometimes remind us of what it could have been.