Located at 1807 North Main Street in High Point, Otto and Blue serves Italian cuisine. It is open from 5-9 Tuesday-Thursday, 5-9:30 Friday and Saturday, and closed Sunday and Monday. There is a full bar, and online reservations are available.
Magnolia Blue was one of my favorite High Point eateries. Whether I went for weekend brunch or New Year’s Eve dinner, I never had a bad meal there. It closed in early February for what were supposed to be renovations, only to reopen months later with a new name and a new concept, trading slightly upscale Southern for more upscale Italian. In some regards, this makes sense – it fills a void created by the closure of Lulu and Blu – but in other ways, it’s a massive gamble.
My wife and I went for our anniversary dinner, and while it was an overall pleasant experience, it also made us miss Magnolia. The higher price point is the chief culprit. Otto and Blue offers pastas in the $20s and entrees starting in the $30s, bread and olive oil not included. While we were celebrating an occasion that merited such a splurge, it’s hard to imagine the restaurant remaining competitive at those prices once the sheen of newness wears off.
Look past that, however, and Otto and Blue shines in both ambiance and service. It’s classy without being stuffy, and the dark turquoise tones suit it well. Allison, a Magnolia Blue mainstay, was personable and attentive and provided excellent service throughout the meal.
Otto and Blue’s menu offers apps, salads, pastas, and entrees. It’s predominantly Italian albeit with a few options for the steak-and-potatoes crowd. The dishes range from recognizably classic (rigatoni Bolognese) to conspicuously elevated (halibut piccatta). After mulling over several offerings, we went with the bread service, tagliatelle, and duck cacciatore.
The food ranged from fairly good to outstanding. While $9 for bread is a tough pill to swallow, they executed it as well as they possibly could have: a hot, fresh ciabatta with tasty herb butter, olive relish, and a quality olive oil-balsamic combo as accompaniments. The cacciatore boasted a pair of duck legs confit, and while I’m usually no fan of dark meat poultry, these were prepared well with crispy skin and plenty of meat. For a typically hearty dish, the sauce seemed light (and a bit subdued), but that could be a consequence of serving atop polenta (more absorbent) rather than pasta. Speaking of pastas and sauces, the tagliatelle hit a nice balance of creamy and zesty without swimming in its white wine lemon sauce. Surprisingly, the highlight of the meal ended up being the dessert that Otto and Blue kindly offered as an anniversary gift. A scoop of vanilla bean gelato came adorned with a Biscoff cookie, a drizzle of olive oil, and a dash of salt. If salt and especially olive oil on ice cream seem vaguely blasphemous, don’t knock it until you try it. Each bite was thoroughly delicious.
It's a
given that good food doesn’t come cheap, but even so, Otto and Blue has no
margin for error to justify what it charges. On food alone, it was close but
not quite there. However, the overall experience made it worthwhile, and I have
no regrets about dining here.








