In Oklahoma, beekeeper/honey producer/bluegrass musician Amziah King (Matthew McConaughey) is called upon to solve a variety of problems in his community, including helping law enforcement to identify the source of some stolen honey. He is soon joined by Kateri (Angelina LookingGlass), his now-grown former foster daughter who has returned to the area after the death of her mother. Just as Kateri begins to find a sense of belonging, tragedy strikes, and she's left to right a terrible wrong.
Writer-director Andrew Patterson's sophomore effort is an ambitious hodgepodge of genres and tones. At different times, The Rivals of Amziah King is a heartfelt family drama, a black comedy farce, and a crime/revenge thriller. There are moments of shocking gore, moments of serene stillness, and even a school sequence that plays like a live-action King of the Hill (right down to Scott Shepherd's turn as Amziah's heavily accented, Boomhaueresque colleague). This kitchen sink approach can be disorienting, and the film is not without other flaws. At its worst, it's gratingly sentimental, and it delivers its message with patronizing obviousness. That said, the parts that work work really well.
The movie's acting is a study in contrasts. McConaughey brings an intense upbeat charisma to Amziah. It's a quirky, showy performance that he somehow still pulls off. LookingGlass, a relative newcomer opposite McConaughey's industry vet, more than holds her own. Kateri has a steely resolve, but even at her most vengeful, she never loses her humanity. Kurt Russell makes the most of his minimal screentime, imbuing cutthroat crooked businessman Dob McCoy with folksy charm. The rest of the cast includes Jake Horowitz and Cole Sprouse as Kateri's shady-but-well-meaning allies.
Aesthetically, The Rivals of Amziah King is almost as uneven as it is tonally. The sun-and-soil visuals help to establish sense of place (even though the movie was not filmed in Oklahoma), but the editing features some rather jarring cuts. The score includes bluegrass and folk tunes as expected alongside heavy classical pieces. While the latter give certain moments some dramatic heft, they do feel overused to the point of intrusion.
The Rivals of Amziah King is nothing if not ambitious. Even if Patterson arguably stretched himself too thin here, he showed enough vision to suggest that viable alternatives to cookie cutter fanservice are still alive and well.










