After
being elected President of the United States, former general Thaddeus
“Thunderbolt” Ross (Harrison Ford, replacing the late William Hurt) pushes for
an international treaty that would prevent an arms race and allow for shared
extraction of adamantium, an advanced extraterrestrial metal. He also seeks the
help of Captain America, Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) to re-form the Avengers, a
superhero group Ross once opposed. Wilson is skeptical, but when a series of
coordinated attacks jeopardize Ross’s plans and threaten to trigger a war, Cap
and his protégé Joaquin “Falcon” Torres (Danny Ramirez) vow to get to the
bottom of it before someone they care about takes the fall.
The standard
knock on Marvel movies these days is that they’ve become too insular, too
creatively sterile, and too dependent on quippy dialogue and slick CGI to do
more than briefly (or, in the case of runtime bloat, not-so-briefly) entertain.
Truth be told, Brave New World, the fourth Captain America film (though
the first to star Mackie in the role), won’t do much to challenge those
perceptions. And yet to call it “bad” wouldn’t really be fair. Even after
reshoots and delays, no one should confuse this with a Zack Snyder film
butchered by meddling executives or a Fant4stic doomed by directorial
incompetence. The worst that can be said about Brave New World is that
it is neither brave nor new, playing as a muted version of what Marvel
previously did much better in projects like Captain America: The Winter
Soldier and even The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.
The one unblemished
bright spot is the addition of Ford, a controversial choice given that other
Marvel characters (cough T’Challa cough) were not recast when the actor died.
Hurt’s version went from Ahabesque Hulk hunter to obstructive politician, never
the worst person the heroes had to face but a consistently unpleasant jerk
nevertheless. Ford’s version keeps the character’s rough edges (stubbornness,
selfishness, and pride) but adds a layer of melancholic regret. He’s believable
as a man who knows he’s caused a lot of damage (alienating his daughter in the
process) and is trying to do better.
Everyone
else is solid even though they aren’t given enough to work with. Mackie is a
good fit for the title role, yet he doesn’t have the room to spread his acting
wings that The Falcon and the Winter Soldier afforded him. He sometimes
seems sidelined in what is nominally his movie. Giancarlo Esposito has made
menacing villains his stock and trade as of late, and he appears briefly as
terrorist leader Sidewinder here. He supplies a physical threat, but the
character isn’t particularly memorable. More distinction was granted to Tim
Blake Nelson’s mad scientist Samuel Sterns, last seen getting infected by gamma-radiated
blood way back in 2008’s The Incredible Hulk. Nelson’s creepy calm tilts the character away from garden-variety megalomania, but Sterns comes across petty, and
the character design does him no favors. Shira Haas as national security
advisor Ruth Bat-Seraph had the potential to bring something interesting to the
mix, but instead of the comics’ Israeli superheroine, she’s depicted as an
ex-Black Widow: still formidable but a type of character we’ve seen several
times before.
“We’ve
seen this before” applies to the feel of several of the film’s action set
pieces as well, be they aerial battles or Captain America going hand-to-hand
against a tough mercenary. That said, the pacing is brisk without being rushed.
What Julius Onah’s direction lacks in distinction it makes up for in
competence. The visual effects, derided by some critics, aren’t really poor.
Malcolm
Spellman, who created The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, was one of Brave
New World’s co-writers though you wouldn’t really know it. Whereas the show
was guilty of occasional grandstanding, it wasn’t afraid to engage complex
issues. This movie gives a nod to the power of representation before breezily
zipping along to the next plot point. It’s enough for some – and too much for
racist idiots — but it will leave others wondering what a bolder version of
this movie might have been.