Sunday, July 14, 2013

Cherry Pit Cafe and Pie Shop

Located at 411B Pisgah Church Road in Greensboro, Cherry Pit specializes in pies both sweet and savory. The restaurant also offers soups, salads, sandwiches, burgers, and home-style entrees. Catering is available.

Tucked into the Village at North Elm shopping center, the Cherry Pit exudes a whimsical charm that belies its cookie-cutter surroundings. A grinning cherry logo greets patrons into the small (fewer than a dozen tables) storefront. Inside, signs bearing slogans like “Money can’t buy happiness, but it can buy pie!” spruce up the walls. If the display case featuring a bevy of delectable slices doesn’t put you at ease, then the accommodating, industrious, red-shirted staff probably will.

Given the care that the mom-and-pop owners have put into creating a unique and thoughtful (minus the déclassé plastic silverware) environment, it is a shame that the food is decidedly unremarkable. The menu does offer a decent variety with some intriguing sides, but the execution is uneven. The pot pies sampled (one chicken, the other seafood) had a creamy, flavorful filling but a dry, doughy crust that called to mind an unseasoned biscuit. Zucchini bites had a welcome spicy kick, yet an order of mac and cheese was Velveeta-like and lacked a homemade touch. Still, the amount of food (a pot pie/entrée and two sides for $10) represented a fair value for the price.

Dessert is a different story. The slice of pie sampled – cherry cream cheese – was rich, creamy, and expertly executed. It was also not particularly large, and unlike the meal pricing, the $4+ charged felt like a stretch.

The Cherry Pit is full of character, tasty pie, and good intentions. As it is a new (opened early July) venture, there is still time for the kitchen to raise the bar and hammer out the inconsistencies. Until then, it’s a pleasant enough place when not jam packed but not worth fighting a line for pricey pie, no matter how delectable.


7.25/10


Cherry Pit Cafe on Urbanspoon

No comments:

Post a Comment