A plot
synopsis and review of the theatrical cut can be found here.
This movie’s
troubled production is practically a film’s worth of drama unto itself. Since
2013’s Man of Steel, director Snyder had established himself as the DC
Extended Universe’s divisive cinematic architect, cranking out films that were
visually distinctive but narrative lacking. Much like Marvel’s The Avengers,
Justice League was meant to be the culmination of several films’ worth
of build-up. However, Snyder stepped away from the film following the death of
his daughter, and Warner Brothers brought in Joss Whedon to rewrite, reshoot,
and finish the production. The resulting movie, while not abysmal, was nevertheless
disappointing, and between studio-mandated cuts and allegations of Whedon’s
misconduct, it wasn’t long before fans started clamoring for Snyder’s original film
to be completed. Finally, in 2020, Snyder reassembled the original cast for
re-shoots, and the completed film launched last month on HBO Max.
So after
years of controversy and anticipation and many millions of dollars spent, did Justice
League get it right the second time around? Yes and no. For starters, this
is a film that demands some affinity for the source material. With a four-hour
runtime, it will feel torturous to those who are apathetic toward comic books
and test the patience of even those who hold a more favorable view. That caveat
aside, Snyder and co-writer Chris Terrio deserve credit for what they’ve been
able to pull off here. Snyder has often referred to DC superheroes as
mythological figures, and this film reflects that sensibility. The grandiosity,
visual splendor, and violence have all been ratcheted up, and Darkseid,
previously an unseen menace, appears here in the flesh, given gravitas courtesy
of Ray Porter’s menacingly deep vocal performance. But this is not another
eye-rolling all style, no substance affair. The added runtime addresses several
of the pacing and character development problems that have plagued previous DCEU
films. Barry Allen/The Flash (Ezra Miller) and especially Victor Stone/Cyborg
(Ray Fisher) are given a fuller backstory, and Fisher uses the opportunity to
make Victor, already a conflicted and tragic figure, arguably the film’s most
relatable and sympathetic character.
When all
is said and done, however, Snyder’s Justice League is still a flawed film. The dialogue
feels at times expository, the score is lackluster, and the film suffers from a
bad case of ending fatigue. The latter is especially frustrating as the closing
moments, which hint at scientist Ryan Choi (Ryan Zheng) becoming The Atom and
Ben Affleck’s underrated Batman forming an unlikely alliance with Jared Leto’s much-maligned
(and here, partially redeemed) Joker in a post-apocalyptic future, offer
tantalizing glimpses of future movies that will likely never come to pass.
Snyder and
his collaborators deserve praise for their passion and determination, and this
version of Justice League is definitely a cut (pun intended) above the
theatrical release, but it’s ultimately a movie more appreciated than enjoyed.