Located at 3352 Robinhood Road in the Sherwood Plaza shopping center in Winston-Salem (with the original location still operating at 140 Burke Street), Burke StreetPizza offers New York-style pizza daily. It is open from 11-9 Sunday-Thursday and 11-10 Friday and Saturday. Lunch specials and online ordering are available.
Burke Street Pizza is a classic neighborhood pizza joint, nothing more and nothing less. The interior is dark and dated, which, while not terribly appealing, adds to its bona fides. In addition to pizza, the menu includes fried apps, wings, salads, and hot and cold sandwiches. The availability of grandma pies – a Long Island delicacy – was a pleasant surprise.
I ordered an Italian sandwich and a veggie slice to go. Both were prepared quickly, and while I wouldn’t call service here friendly, it is efficient. The food proved to be fairly satisfying albeit with room for improvement. The sandwich came stuffed with meats (Genoa salami/pepperoni/ham) and veggies though the oil and vinegar was barely discernible. The pizza slice was appreciably huge. Burke Street uses good-quality cheese and a nice sauce as well although the crust isn’t as remarkable. As with other places, for specialty slices, they toss on toppings and re-heat, which means that said toppings don’t get as cooked as long as they ideally should be. Presumably, a whole pie would offer a better texture.
Ultimately,
Burke Street pizza proved more serviceable than sensational. You could do a lot
worse if a pizza craving hits, but don’t expect to be blown away.





